1 John 4:20 · World English Bible
1 John 4:20 Meaning If a Man Says
If a man says, “I love God,” and hates his brother, he is a liar; for he who doesn’t love his brother whom he has seen, how can he love God whom he has not seen?
What does 1 John 4:20 mean?
Ṣidq: Truthfulness Ṣidq is the agreement between what someone says and what they are. Saying you love God costs nothing, since God does not stand there arguing back.
From the Sufism reading below.
1 John 4:20 through 1 lens
The same verse, read by one tradition.
Sufism
SUFISM
Sufism
Ṣidq: Truthfulness Ṣidq is the agreement between what someone says and what they are. Saying you love God costs nothing, since God does not stand there arguing back. How a person feels about someone they know by name reports the state of their heart more accurately than any sentence about God.
Ḥiqd: A grudge that has settled in the heart Al-Ghazali gives the name ḥiqd to anger that has cooled and stayed. He describes how quietly it works: the wishing well stops, a small lift comes when the person fails, a distance opens that looks like nothing. None of that is visible from outside, so someone can carry it for years while their prayers still feel warm.
None of you believes until he loves for his brother what he loves for himself: love has a measure The Prophet put the bar there, and it is easy to check against. Hatred rarely announces itself; it arrives as small wishes, hoping someone gets passed over, hoping the bad story about them holds up. Wanting good for a person the way you want it for yourself and holding a grudge against them cannot both happen at once.
al-Ḥubb fī Allāh: Loving for God's sake The phrase means love that reaches a person because of God. Al-Ghazali makes the plain point that loving anyone spills onto whatever belongs to them, their children, their work, even their handwriting. Love for God that changes nothing in how someone treats the people God made has stayed a feeling and gone no further.
I was sick and you did not visit me: God is met through people In one saying the Prophet reports God speaking directly, telling a servant He was hungry, thirsty and ill, and went untended. The servant objects that God needs none of this, and the answer is that God was with the one who did. By God's own telling, He is reached through the neighbour, so warmth that steps around the neighbour reaches nothing.
Tajallī: Self-disclosure Tajallī is God showing Himself through the forms of the world, and Ibn Arabi holds that a human being is the fullest of them. An unseen God never interrupts, disappoints, or gets on your nerves, so loving Him takes little effort. The person standing in front of someone is where love for God either shows up or does not.
Sufism lensGo deeper in the app
Sufism lens
Live 1 John 4:20 today
- Think of someone whose bad news would give you a small private lift. That reaction is worth taking seriously, and the way back is to quietly wish them something good today.
- Today, give one person your actual attention: phone down, face up, no half-listening while you scroll. Warmth that cannot survive putting the phone down was never quite warmth.
- When a family member or coworker does the thing that gets on your nerves, stay kind in that exact moment. That is where your love for anything larger either shows up or does not.
Who am I keeping a cold distance from while telling myself I am a loving person?
The same truth in other traditions
Confucius · Analects
Asked for the one thread running through everything, he said: do not do to others what you would not want done to you, and let that be the test of a person's character rather than their fine words.
Judaism · Hillel
Standing on one foot, he summed the whole teaching as not doing to your neighbour what you would hate yourself, and called everything else commentary on that.
Zen · Linji
People go looking for the sacred somewhere far off, and miss that it has been standing right here in ordinary company the whole time.
Free · No account needed
Read all of 1 John 4 through 17 lenses
Lensightful opens every verse of the Bible through the traditions you choose. Save readings, ask a follow-up question, and get one verse a day.
Get Lensightful on the App Store