Open in the app
Mid-century illustration of an oil lamp and an open scroll on a table, disciples talking by the sea of Galilee

John 9:16 · World English Bible

John 9:16 Meaning Some Therefore of the Pharisees Said

Some therefore of the Pharisees said, “This man is not from God, because he doesn’t keep the Sabbath.” Others said, “How can a man who is a sinner do such signs?” There was division among them.

Read it in the app

What does John 9:16 mean?

When a healing appears in its midst, the mind that judges by rule cannot receive it, for the correction did not come the way fear expected and so must be condemned as coming from no true source. Guilt would rather protect its law than acknowledge the love that broke it, and it calls the miracle a sin because a miracle undoes the very belief in sin on which it stands.

From the Christian Psychology reading below.

John 9:16 through 1 lens

The same verse, read by one tradition.

CHRISTIAN PSYCHOLOGY

Christian Psychology

When a healing appears in its midst, the mind that judges by rule cannot receive it, for the correction did not come the way fear expected and so must be condemned as coming from no true source. Guilt would rather protect its law than acknowledge the love that broke it, and it calls the miracle a sin because a miracle undoes the very belief in sin on which it stands.

Yet the same evidence splits the judging mind against itself. One part clings to the rule, another cannot deny the good it has seen, and this division is what always happens when love enters a mind still ruled by fear, until the mind must at last choose which teacher it will follow.

Pharisees: the part of the mind that judges by law and guards its rules, the ego defending its order against the miracle it cannot explain

Christian Psychology lensGo deeper in the app

Christian Psychology lens

Live John 9:16 today

  1. Pick one strong opinion you hold and let yourself sit with the evidence against it for a few minutes without defending. That discomfort is the sound of something loosening.
  2. When someone does something good in a way you disapprove of, say the good part out loud first. The urge to add but is the rule talking.
  3. In a meeting or a group chat where a decision broke the usual way and worked, resist leading with why it should not have been allowed. Ask what it did instead.

Am I defending a rule today, or the good it was supposed to protect?

The same truth in other traditions

Zhuangzi

He mocked the scholars who measured the sea with a cup and declared the rest did not exist. What will not fit the rule gets denied rather than looked at.

Zen

The finger pointing at the moon is not the moon. People defend the finger and miss what it was there for.

Stoicism · Epictetus

He said it is impossible to learn what you already think you know. The certainty itself is what blocks the door.

Mid-century illustration of Jesus teaching the crowd on a hillside above the sea

Free · No account needed

Read all of John 9 through 17 lenses

Lensightful opens every verse of the Bible through the traditions you choose. Save readings, ask a follow-up question, and get one verse a day.

Get Lensightful on the App Store