Mid-century illustration of a calm sea at dawn

1 John 4:10 · World English Bible

1 John 4:10 Meaning In This Is Love

In this is love, not that we loved God, but that he loved us, and sent his Son as the atoning sacrifice for our sins.

What does 1 John 4:10 mean?

Love begins on God's side. Human affection for God answers something already done rather than causing it, which means no one has to earn their way into being wanted.

From the Orthodox reading below.

1 John 4:10 through 2 lenses

The same verse, read by 2 traditions.

ORTHODOX

Orthodox

Love begins on God's side. Human affection for God answers something already done rather than causing it, which means no one has to earn their way into being wanted.

Propitiation sounds like calming down a furious God, as though the Father had to be talked out of punishing, and the sending undoes that picture: love came first and moved the whole thing. What the Son took on was the sickness of sin in human nature, cleansing the meeting place between God and people. God's disposition needed no change. Ours did, and the cure had to be delivered in person, inside a real human life.

SUFISM

Sufism

He loves them and they love Him: God's love is named first Sufi teachers return to that line from the Quran and keep pointing at the order of the words. Someone measuring their standing by how much love they can work up in themselves has the sequence backwards. Their warmth is an answer to something already sent, which lifts the whole weight of having to feel enough.

Faḍl: favor given before it is earned Faḍl covers everything handed to a person that no effort of theirs paid for. Most people keep a quiet ledger with God, expecting affection to arrive in proportion to good behavior. Love that showed up before the ledger opened makes the accounting pointless, and the relief of that is what gratitude feels like from the inside.

Not only the thirsty seek water, the water seeks the thirsty too: the search runs both ways Rumi wrote that line about how a longing rarely begins on the side that feels it. A person can spend years believing the entire effort of reaching God rests on them, and grow worn out in it. Reading the pull they feel as evidence of being wanted turns the effort from chasing into answering.

My mercy comes before my anger: mercy arrives ahead of judgment The Prophet passed these words on as God speaking about Himself. Guilt makes a person assume God meets them first with anger, so any later kindness feels like a reprieve they argued their way into. Putting mercy in front reverses that: the kindness was already in place before the wrong was ever done.

Fidāʾ: a ransom paid in someone's place Fidāʾ names a life bought back by something given in exchange for it. Ibn Arabi lingers over the Quran's account of a son ransomed by a sacrifice that God supplied, not the father. Someone carrying a debt they cannot pay finds it settled by the one they owed, and settled before they grasped its size.

Orthodox lens

Live 1 John 4:10 today

  1. Before you do anything useful today, sit still for two minutes and let yourself be wanted without having produced anything. Resist the urge to make it count.
  2. Do one kind thing for someone who cannot repay you and will not know it was you: pay the small bill, clean the shared thing, send the help with no name on it.
  3. When you fall short at work and the familiar reflex says earn your way back, stop. Finish the task well and let the wanting of you stay where it already was, untouched by your performance.

What am I still trying to buy that was handed to me first?

The same truth in other traditions

Hinduism · Bhakti tradition

The cat's kitten is carried by the scruff of the neck and does nothing but hang there. The devotee is held first and loves back second.

Sufism · Rumi

He says no lover would ever go seeking the beloved if the beloved were not already seeking him. The longing you feel was planted in you from the other side.

Taoism · Tao Te Ching 8

Water does not wait to be invited; it goes to the low places and nourishes without asking anything in return. The movement starts on the giving side.

Mid-century illustration of Jesus teaching the crowd on a hillside above the sea

Free · No account needed

Read all of 1 John 4 through 17 lenses

Lensightful opens every verse of the Bible through the traditions you choose. Save readings, ask a follow-up question, and get one verse a day.

Get Lensightful on the App Store