Open in the app
Mid-century illustration of an oil lamp and an open scroll on a table, disciples talking by the sea of Galilee

John 5:10 · World English Bible

John 5:10 Meaning So the Jews Said to Him

So the Jews said to him who was cured, “It is the Sabbath. It is not lawful for you to carry the mat.”

Read it in the app

What does John 5:10 mean?

A mind has just been made whole, and the first response of the guarding part is not gladness but accusation. It does not see the healing; it sees a rule, and measures the healed against it, insisting the very sign of freedom is forbidden.

From the Christian Psychology reading below.

John 5:10 through 1 lens

The same verse, read by one tradition.

CHRISTIAN PSYCHOLOGY

Christian Psychology

A mind has just been made whole, and the first response of the guarding part is not gladness but accusation. It does not see the healing; it sees a rule, and measures the healed against it, insisting the very sign of freedom is forbidden. This is how the ego meets every miracle, by consulting its law of when good is permitted and finding the good unlawful because it did not come by the ego's leave.

What once could not be carried now rests lightly in the hands, the burden that pinned the man turned into a thing he bears with ease. Yet fear stares at that reversal and calls it a transgression, for the ego would rather defend its rules than rejoice that someone can walk. A mind that judges by the ordinance always misses the healing in front of it.

Sabbath: the ego's ordinance of when good is allowed, the fixed rule the mind invokes to condemn a healing it did not sanction Bed: what once carried the helpless mind and is now carried by it, the old burden made light by wholeness yet mistaken by fear for an offense

Christian Psychology lensGo deeper in the app

Christian Psychology lens

Live John 5:10 today

  1. When something good happens at the wrong time, a text from a friend during your focused hour, a call while you are cooking, pause before you decide it is an interruption. Let it be good first, then decide what to do.
  2. Next time someone close to you changes for the better and you catch yourself wanting to point out they did it the wrong way, or too late, say the glad thing out loud instead and keep the correction to yourself.
  3. In a meeting or a group chat where someone breaks the usual process but gets something right, be the one who says it worked, before anyone starts in on how it was done.

Where in my day do I keep a rule about when good news is allowed to arrive?

The same truth in other traditions

Confucianism · Mencius

Asked whether a man may touch his drowning sister-in-law when ritual forbids it, Mencius answers that to leave her to drown for the sake of the rule is the act of a beast. The rule serves the person, never the reverse.

Zen

Two monks reach a flooded ford where a young woman cannot cross. One carries her over, breaking the rule he lives by, and walks on lightly. The other carries his outrage for miles.

Stoicism · Epictetus

When you are upset, it is not the event that troubles you but your judgment of it. The man carrying his bed is simply a man carrying his bed until your opinion turns him into an offender.

Mid-century illustration of Jesus teaching the crowd on a hillside above the sea

Free · No account needed

Read all of John 5 through 17 lenses

Lensightful opens every verse of the Bible through the traditions you choose. Save readings, ask a follow-up question, and get one verse a day.

Get Lensightful on the App Store